Christmas Cookie Round-Up

This year we made some great Christmas cookies and while most of the recipes were from other bloggers, I wanted to keep track of what we made and the minor changes I did to some of the recipes so we can use them again next year.  So, here are the links to what we made and how we made them our own!

*Two notes… First, while I am generally dairy-free as well as gluten and corn free, I have found that I can tolerate some butter so many of the recipes do include it.  Second, in any recipe that calls for an all-purpose gluten free flour, I used the Namaste mix that you can find at Costco.  It worked great and I was even able to sub it one-for-one for regular all-purpose flour in my family’s traditional Belgium cookies.

1. Gingerbread Men and Royal Icing


I love gingerbread cookies and I love to do cut-outs with the boys each year.  The cookie recipe was fairly simple and the only change I made was leaving out the xanthan gum (my flour mix had it in it already) and using arrowroot powder in lieu of cornstarch.

For the Royal Icing, I needed a recipe that didn’t use confectioner’s sugar as that is made of white sugar and corn starch.  Seriously, corn is in everything!  😦  This recipe uses regular granulated sugar.  While mine didn’t stiffen up as well as the recipe indicated, it got thick enough for the boys to pipe it out onto the cookies.

I think for next year with these two recipes, I would like to work on finding a way to make these without refined sugar at all but for this year, we let go a little and just enjoyed them!

2.  Peanut Butter Balls


Oh goodness were these delicious!!!  And, truly, they really aren’t too unhealthy for you with just simple ingredients: dates, peanut butter, oatmeal, coconut oil, dark chocolate.  The only change I made to this recipe was that I used an unsalted peanut butter so I added a pinch of sea salt to the mix.  Oh, and we made a double batch of these because they were just so good.  These may become a year-round treat at our house instead of just at Christmas treat!  🙂

3.  Butter Crunch Toffee


One of my all time favorite Christmas treats that my dad always made when we were younger is Butter Crunch Toffee.  I love it!  But, unfortunately it has corn syrup as one of the ingredients.  Boo!  So, I came across the following recipe that was quite similar to my family’s original.  When my dad and I made it this year, he and I agreed that it turned out even better than the original recipe!  And, I love that it uses maple syrup and no refined sugars!  How awesome is that.

The main changes we made to the recipe were using chopped walnuts instead of almonds, and using unsweetened chocolate on both the top and the bottom of the toffee rather than semi-sweet chocolate on one side.  The other thing that we did was use a candy thermometer, getting the toffee to a hard crack before adding the nuts.

This toffee was so good that we ate it all up well before Christmas even happened and needed to make a second batch. Yum!!!!

4.  Belgium Cookies


When I first started cutting out gluten, one of the foods I most mourned not being able to eat were our family’s traditional Belgium Cookies.  While it is a family recipe and I am not going to publish it here, I just wanted to make note that by using Namaste flour mix one-to-one in the original recipe worked great.  They are such a treat!!! I LOVED that this recipe turned out and tasted so close to the original that even my dad, the Belgium Cookie maker of the family thought they were a close match.  Yay!



One response

  1. Thanks so much for trying my Peanut Butter Ball recipe! It looks like they turned out perfectly. Glad they were tasty.

    And that Butter Crunch Toffee made with maple syrup sounds amazing. I think I need to try that recipe next year. Pinning it now. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Our Growing Paynes

A journey about cooking, traveling, gardening, and crafting.

Pastor Dale Jenkins

Encouragement, Faith, and Hope for the Journey

Clare Smith

Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"

Eat the cookie!

before the cookie eats you...

Life Shared and Loved

A blog written by Krysta Kemp on all areas of life loved.

Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"

Spiritual Table

One girl's quest to learn why food is a matter of faith.

oil-istas - The oil-istas Blog

Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"

Bee Baby Blog

Real food, baby stuff and awesomeness

Sugar-Free Mom

Just another site

Keeper of the Home

Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"

Proverbs and Pacifiers

Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"

The Better Mom

Growing Better Together

Organizing Made Fun

Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"

I'm an Organizing Junkie

Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"


Or, a way to answer the question, "What's for dinner?"

%d bloggers like this: